Skip to main content

The Mind Talk

Background image
Illustration of an adult woman and a child smiling and high-fiving over an open book at a table.
Praise is one of the most natural parts of human interaction. So stopping it altogether is indeed difficult. However, the better part is that much of the research suggests praise to be a motivator and guide for your children and teens. But there are instances when praise can be harmful. For example, if you’re using praise to meet your own ends while parenting your teens, it is likely to go wrong. Therefore, it is important to praise only when it is an honest expression – this way, it will likely be neutral or helpful. Understanding how praise affects your child is an important part of parenting mental health, as it shapes how children view themselves, respond to challenges, and develop confidence over time.

Characteristics of Praise

Praise can either increase motivation or decrease it. But whether or not praise is beneficial depends on when and how it is used. While praise is a complex phenomenon, here are a few guidelines as to when and why praise will—and will not—be beneficial.

Praise Should Be Sincere

Praise increases motivation if the teen’s self-concept changes because of it. For instance, When a student receives praise from someone they respect, such as a teacher, for putting in effort even when a task is challenging, it can shape how they see themselves. They may begin to think, “I am someone who doesn’t give up easily, even when things get difficult.” Over time, this positive self-image can influence their behaviour, encouraging them to persevere through challenges and approach difficult tasks with greater confidence. Sincerity is one of the keys to effective praise. If praise isn’t sincere, the behaviour may not improve or get worse. Certain conditions under which praise is ineffective are:

  • Dishonesty: If the teen perceives praise as not truthful, he/she is simply going to dismiss it. Global, effusive praises (“You are the smartest boy ever!”) are at a higher risk of being viewed as insincere than specific praise (“You did very well on that set of problems”). For example, if a teenager knows they barely prepared for an exam, being told, “You’re brilliant at everything you do!” may feel exaggerated and make the parent’s praise less believable.
  • Control: Praise may also be insincere if the purpose is not to congratulate the student, but rather to control him. In this case, it means that the praise includes language meant to direct what the child does. For example, “Good job on your journal entry; you should write that legibly every day.” Using controlling or directing language makes the praiseworthy behaviour less interesting and does not change the teen’s self-concept.
  • Unearned: Praise may also go wrong if the parent tries too hard to boost the teen’s motivation or self-esteem. While parents may praise their teen to make them feel better about disappointing results, teenagers may interpret this praise as a sign that their parents do not believe they are capable of doing better. For example, when a teenager scores poorly on a test, a parent says, “That’s wonderful, at least you passed!” may unintentionally communicate low expectations. Rather than feeling encouraged, the teenager might assume their parents believe this is the best they can manage. Over time, such praise may undermine their confidence and make them feel underestimated rather than supported.

Praise Should Emphasize Process, Not Ability

While parenting your teens, praise can either be about the product of their work (“That is a wonderful story”) or some attribute of the process that went into making the product (“I’m proud of your hard work on that story”) or their ability (“You are a great writer”). While all of these can have a positive effect on motivation in the short run, some of these may have negative effects in the long run. In terms of intelligence, children usually have a fixed or malleable view. Those who take a fixed view believe that intelligence is a basic characteristic about an individual that cannot be changed. And those with the malleable view believe that intelligence can be changed, depending on what a person does. Based on these views, teens also have different beliefs about failure and the value of effort. For the child with the fixed view, failure is very negative. They may view a single test as a measure of their intelligence for the rest of their lives. Children with the malleable view are less concerned about failure because they do not view performance on any one task as a reflection of how smart they are, and because they believe that if they do fail, there is something they can do about it: Try harder! To know this is important because one important source of these views is the type of praise that children get from adults. If parents praise what the teens are (such as “smart”), they attribute their success to a fixed character that they possess. If parents praise something the teens do (such as focus on the task), they attribute their success to their efforts, which are under their control.

Praising a child for being intelligent may boost their confidence initially, but it can sometimes make challenges harder to handle in the long run. When children are repeatedly praised for their abilities, they may feel pressured to maintain the image of being “smart” and avoid tasks where they might struggle or make mistakes. In contrast, children who are encouraged for their effort may be more willing to take on challenges because they see difficulties as opportunities to learn. For example, a teenager who is constantly praised for being naturally good at maths may avoid difficult questions for fear of getting them wrong, while a teenager who values effort may be more willing to practise and learn from mistakes.

Praise Should Be Immediate and Unexpected

Praise should follow the praiseworthy act to be the most beneficial. For instance, if the mother praises her teen for cleaning his/her room two weeks later, it would have little to no effect on the repetition of the task. The trickier issue is the predictability with which the child is praised. Praise that comes like clockwork presents a potential problem: The child may start to work with the expectation of being praised. Therefore, doling out praise like clockwork will be of no benefit either to the parent or the child. The idea is to get the teen intrinsically motivated rather than to gather praise. The goal is not simply to get the child to stop asking for praise; it is to help the child to think of his/her work differently—as something that is done for the teen’s own satisfaction, not to garner praise from the parent. For example, if a teenager puts their phone away and starts studying independently, a parent might say, “I noticed you got started without a reminder. That shows initiative.”

Praising Effectively

Research from the De Montfort University Leicester had concluded that praising your teens at least 5 times a day leads to better and calmer behaviour and lower inattention as compared to those who aren’t praised. Therefore, it is important for parents to catch their children while engaging in good behaviors and intentionally praise them as a reward. This strategy works because it encourages parents to focus on positive actions and teaches children that they will win praise and attention for good behaviour. Here are a few useful tips to praise your teens effectively:

  • Increase the number of times you praise your teens by looking out for their good behaviours and saying so.
  • Say exactly what you are happy about so your child knows what you mean and the likelihood of that behavior increases.
  • Praise their efforts rather than their abilities as this leads to a better response from the teens.
  • Instead of waiting until the child does something perfectly, notice little changes and recognise them.

For example, instead of saying, “You’re the best sibling,” a parent could say, “I noticed you patiently helped your younger brother with his homework. That was thoughtful of you.”

Praise can be a powerful way to encourage children and teenagers, but its impact depends on how sincerely, thoughtfully, and meaningfully it is offered. Learning how to praise thoughtfully is also one way to understand how to support a child’s mental health, helping children feel valued for who they are while encouraging them to learn, grow, and navigate difficulties with confidence. The goal is not to praise every action or celebrate every outcome, but to help children recognise their efforts, learn from mistakes, and develop confidence that does not depend entirely on external approval. By offering specific, genuine, and timely praise, parents can encourage positive behaviour while helping their children develop a sense of motivation that comes from within. Rather than focusing only on achievements or natural abilities, acknowledging persistence, progress, and willingness to try can help children approach challenges with greater confidence. Ultimately, enough praise is not about reaching a fixed number every day; it is about making children feel seen and supported without making them feel that they must earn their worth through success.

Photo Credits: Visual Generation

Citations

De Montfort University Leicester. (2019). Research shows praising children five times a day has positive impact. De Montfort University Leicester.

https://www.dmu.ac.uk/about-dmu/news/2019/october/research-shows-praising-children-five-times-a-day-has-positive-impact.aspx 

Willingham, D. (2005). How praise can motivate—or stifle. American Educator, 29(4), 23-27.

Sakshi

About the author

Sakshi is a clinical psychologist with a deep passion for understanding human behavior, a strong drive for research, and a keen eye for psychological intricacies. Committed to continuous learning, she seeks to explore every facet of psychology, from theory to practice, to better support and empower individuals. With a curiosity that fuels her pursuit of knowledge, she strives to bridge the gap between research and real-world applications, making psychology more accessible and impactful.

Recently Added

Diet and mood regulation.

Depression affects over 330 million people worldwide and is characterised by low or irregular mood, sleep disturbance and loss of interest or …

At least once in our lifetimes, we have been involved in or enmeshed in unhealthy and manipulative relationships where we have, knowingly …

Praise is one of the most natural parts of human interaction. So stopping it altogether is indeed difficult. However, the better part …